Al, I'm Sorry: The Most Depressing Iowa Season of My Life
Al Young deserved better.
Damien Sims, Tommy Busch, Klink, Humpal, Iwebema, Mattison, Godfrey, even Adam Fucking Shada. They all deserved better than this.
Tonight it appears highly likely Iowa's 2007 season is over. They have finished 6-6 (4-4), with losses against such juggernauts as Iowa State (3-9) and Western Michigan (4-7). One in ten Iowa football players was implicated in criminal activity of one kind or another. That's not a misprint. One in ten. The man in charge, who keeps telling us to stay the course and retains his assistant coaches despite a demonstrated lack of results, made 2100% more than the governor for presiding over this debacle.
This was a small but great group of seniors. Al Young, despite a seemingly never-ending string of injuries, will leave with the fourth-most rushing yards in the history of Iowa football. Mattison, Iwebema, Klinkenborg, and Humpal, who replaced Iowa legends in the defensive front 7, will leave on nearly the same plane as their predecessors. Tom Busch is my favorite player, running and blocking hard all season despite being criminally underutilized by KOK. But their senior efforts, gargantuan and heroic as they may have been, were squandered by this team.
We wasted the best front seven since 2004 on an offensive line which flat out refused to block anyone. We wasted the best running back tandem since Russell/Lewis on a quarterback who couldn't hit an open receiver and receivers who didn't catch the ball when he did. We wasted a tough, classy, downright professional group of seniors on a team filled with convicts and thugs and a coaching staff that was too fucking stubborn to even attempt to fix the all-too-obvious problems.
Obviously an Iowa fan
I try to avoid what SMQ calls "second-guessing the split-second decisions of college kids under extreme physical duress," but it's abundantly clear JC6 doesn't have what we need. His decision-making is too slow, and his passes too erratic, to keep the offense moving. He remains unable to throw a touch pass or hit a receiver coming across the middle, and KOK remains unwilling to call anything but touch passes and routes across the middle. It's not a question of youth or learning curve; he's had three years in this system and he's not an idiot. It's a question of capability. Jake is simply incapable of running this plodding offense. It's not his fault; not many people have what it takes to play quarterback for a BCS-conference football team. I would feel bad about this if I were the only one who has given up, but I don't because I'm not. The natives (especially the dumbasses sitting behind me today who couldn't figure out why we didn't go for 2 when down 7) are restless. The MSM is agitated. Even Dolphin and Podolak, who otherwise have red moustaches from all the kool-aid they've downed, were not-so-subtly throwing in the towel tonight (Dolphin went so far as to say, "I don't know what he's looking at" after JC missed DJK in the end zone). If there's nobody better, we've been duped by coaches and "insiders" for nearly two years, and we're fucked for the foreseeable future (now THAT is alliteration).
Defenders of this coaching staff have repeatedly said, "the coaches put players in position to win, and it's the players' fault for not performing." Assuming (I think incorrectly) that this system would actually lead to success, it's the job of the coaches to prepare these players both schematically and technically. If the players are unable to perform effectively in otherwise correct schemes, the players must be more technically sound, the players must be replaced by those who can perform, or the schemes must be adjusted to account for a lack of talent/knowledge. This is the job of a coach (and I'm looking directly at you, KOK).
I've been through worse years (I started college in 1999; I've seen the bottom of the barrel). But the combination of squandered talent, off-field embarrassment, and head-up-its-collective-ass coaching on display this season has left me sadder and angrier than either 1999 or 2000. Now we go on without a group of leaders who were obviously trying to hold the wagon together with both hands while the wheels spun off. We won't change the coaches. We won't change the blueprint. We won't change a damn thing. If Big Blue finds someone with imagination, and Tressel continues to be Tressel, we won't stand a chance.
But tonight, right now, on behalf of all Iowa fans, I'm sorry Mr. Young. You deserved so much better.
Note: This debacle came at the end of a very bad week for me, and I might be clinically insane right now. Nevertheless, something needs to be said, even if it is in rambling, incoherent form. And 00:44 in that video is one hilarious second.
4 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Rock Bottom
Thank God we have blogs because you are right on with your commentary which is far less than we will hear out of the Iowa media.
My blast text messages to my Hawk friends tonight consisted of the following:
How do you define rock bottom? Iowa football.
When you run a tecmo bowl offense with a shitty QB, you punt alot.
Can we still blame everything on Drew Tate?
Can someone lose a job on the Iowa football staff? Is there ever any accountability? Stop putting lipstick on a pig please.
My friends and I use to say, "In Kirk We Trust."
Never is any saying ever more invalid than it is right now. It is not just about losing to WMichigan at home but it is about his stubborn refusal to make any substance changes on his staff or to try different philosophies. Ferentz punts on the opponsents side of the field, he never goes for it, we sit in no blitz cover 2, we run the same 4 plays over and over.
Hell he would still start Kyle McCann over Banks if given the opportunity again. How bad does Jake have to be before another QB gets a series? You award them scholarships, let them play.
You are right, AY and the seniors deserved better. Things is, the reason I am not mad at them is because they played their A$$es off and they will always be true Hawks to me no matter what.
by MacG on Nov 18, 2007 2:22 AM CST reply actions
Thanks
I really don't want to be crazy message board/blog guy. We try to stay irreverent around here and avoid finger-pointing, but sometimes I just can't help it.
If you wanted to see a clinic in modern college coaching, catch a replay of WVU/Cincy last night. Rich Rodriguez and Brian Kelly are coaching on a completely different level, at least offensively. I'm not advocating the spread at Iowa (we simply don't have the personnel), but a little creativity is desperately needed.
I don't think we can blame anything on Drew Tate anymore. In fact, given the interview earlier this year, Tate might be the only one with any clout who speaks the truth.
Might I suggest a little music (for me, it's been the new Radiohead album, Beck's "Sea Change," and Morrisey's "Viva Hate"), a bottle of Maker's Mark, and a replay of Wisconsin-Minnesota (just as a reminder that it could be worse)
by Patrick Vint on Nov 18, 2007 3:44 PM CST up reply actions
Yes, just about Rock Bottom
The Iowa program is like a drunk that's lost his job, family, and friends, but still thinks that being plastered 24 hours a day is just fine, thank you.
Oh--and he's making 2.8 million a year to do it.
When we admit there's a problem WITH THE COACHES we will finally right this ship.
Thug recruits= Coaches
Poor player (esp QB and O-line) development= Coaches
No bowl game=Coaches
Tired predictable schemes=Coaches
Losing to a 3-6 MAC team ON SENIOR DAY (!)= Coaches
Pissing away Drew Tate's senior season because they played him injured all year and let him get emotionally out of control=Coaches
I've gone beyond Howard Beal--I've become fucking Travis Bickle, ready to take on the whole establishment that is fucking great players like Jodie Foster (Albert Young).
Okay, maybe that's a terrible analogy, but you know what I mean.
Programs on the slide do NOT magically change without some sort of staff shake-up. There's a reason Kansas is 11-0 this year, and it's NOT because their coaches are the same ones they had back in the '90's, because they're not. They changed coaches and they got GOOD.
We've kept all our coaches in recent years yet we're BAD. SOMETHING must change. We can't change 85 players that fast. We've gotta' play with what we got (and there's talent out there--don't let anyone tell you we have less talent than ISU, WMU, and Indiana, boys....)
But we CAN change schemes and coaches.
You talkin' to me? You talkin' to ME?!!
Accountability
Hawkeye State and the director are right on. We do have talent and the last 2 recruiting classes have provided this new influx.
I have been screaming for years to hire someone off Rodriquez's staff to run the Hawks offense.
Oops you are correct, it could be worse and we could be Sota or 4-8, 3-7, etc. Rock Bottom is a little bit extreme but losing out on a bowl because we lost to WMU at home is pretty damn low.
However, it is quite apparent this program is headed in the wrong direction. 18 losses in 3 years. 2 of those seasons we had legitimate pre season Big 10 title aspirations.
My biggest complaint with Hawkeye fans is this lowering the bar crap. "Oh, this is Iowa, we should suck, we can not reload, excuses, blah, excuses, blah."
I understand our demographics put us in a disadvantage in recruiting in state kids but still, those are just excuses.
We are in a major BCS conference in a great college community. We pack our stadium and our fans travel well.
Why can not Iowa compete for the Big 10 title every year? I do not understand these lowered expectations as excuses for the current status our mediocre football program.
Hell, I am not even talking about competing for national titles. God forbid.
I would settle for beating Iowa State, Indiana, and Northwestern on a consistent basis.
In the past few years, the University has jacked ticket prices way up, forced long time fans to pony up more cash or move to shittier seats and sold out prime tailgating spots to Corporations.
I understand the extra revenue was needed to help pay for the Kinnick upgrades and this is the price of admission to compete in big time college athletics.
Is it too much to ask to demand and expect better results for the increased prices placed upon fans?
I just want someone on the football staff to be held accountable for the losing.
ANYONE?
Barta needs serious pressure to force Ferentz to make some changes because the appearance of stubborn passivity to new ideas throughout the Iowa football complex is almost as troubling as the Hawks' lackluster 2007 performance.
by MacG on Nov 18, 2007 10:46 PM CST reply actions

















