Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Madonna Promises No Wardrobe Malfunctions

Better Know An Iowa Football Opponent 2010: Northwestern Wildcats (Part One)

The off-season is a long and tiresome trudge, so how can we best get through it?  By looking ahead to next year, of course.  So, in the spirit of forward thinking, we present a team-by-team look at Iowa's 2010 football opponents (with looks at Illinois and Purdue thrown in for good measure so our Big Televen brethren don't feel ignored).  Next up: meow mix.

NORTHWESTERN WILDCATS (@ Evanston, IL; November 13, 2010)

Where the devil do they play?  At Ryan Field, a half-empty glorified high school field where jNW's dozens of fans gather to trade tips on Ferrari detailing and Armani upkeep.  Oh, and to occasionally watch a bit of the "foot-ball."

What did they do last year?  Won some, lost some, lost another bowl game.  Rinse, repeat.  On the bright side, they went to a bowl game for a second consecutive season for just the second time in their history (The other time? 1995-1996, a.k.a. The Big Bang, or The Beginning Of History) and largely maintained the momentum of 2008's 9-win season.  For a program that had grown accustomed to slipping back to life among the Big Ten's dregs for a year or two after every decent season, that's a step forward.

They opened the season with a 47-14 blowout of Towson, but needed a field goal in the closing seconds to avoid blowing a 21-0 lead and heading to overtime against mighty Eastern Michigan (who went 0-12 in 2009).  jNW followed that near-loss with an actual loss against Syracuse -- a Syracuse led by Duke hoopyball refugee Greg Paulus, no less.  The shame in Fitzville only got deeper after they suffered a home loss to Minnesota, but they staunched the bleeding by knocking off Purdue and Miami (OH) in consecutive weeks.  After that, the roller coaster that was the Wildcat season hit another dip as they lost at Michigan State.  The drop was momentarily suspended by a 29-28 win over Indiana that featured them taking advantage of Indiana's own choke-tastic performance before plunging downward again in a 34-13 loss to Penn State in which Mike Kafka, their existential warrior-poet-cum-quarterback, was injured.  Shockingly, a little-used back-up quarterback was rushed into action and unable to pull out a win.  A week later, they returned the favor in the form of the WOOTENOCALYPSE and Iowa fans made their sad faces yet again after a game with Northwestern.  They rode the momentum of the Iowa victory to a pair of wins over ILOLinois and Wisconsin, before crashing back to earth with yet another bowl loss, this time against Auburn in the Outback Bowl.

Much like 2009 Iowa, 2009 Northwestern was XTREEM TO THE BONE, YO and liked to LIVE ON THE EDGE.  Or to put it in vocabulary understandable to those who don't speak the strange tongue of the 15-year old: they played a metric fuckload of close games.  Five of their games were decided by scores in the final three minutes and three more (Iowa, Illinois, Wisconsin) required late defensive stands by Northwestern to preserve a close win.  They went 6-2 in games decided by a touchdown or less; whether or not they were "lucky" in 2009 has been debated ad nauseum, but they probably aren't going to pull off a record like that again if they play so many close games.\

Star-divide

So do they have, like, history with Iowa?  Well, that depends on your perspective.  They're a longstanding member of the Big Ten and Iowa and jNW have been tangling on a regular basis since 1910, with Iowa holding a lopsided 46-22-3 advantage in the overall series.  Of course, since The Beginning Of History in 1995 (which is crazy because I totally remember the '80s and they were bitchin') Northwestern's held a 9-5 advantage, including wins in four of the last five encounters (and three straight in Kinnick).  The Iowa-Northwestern series took on increased importance among their fanbase when Gary Barnett took over in the '90s and made Iowa the black and gold-clad object of their ire, using as many perceived slights as he could latch onto in order to fabricate a rivalry where none had previously existed.  Having been a player under Barnett, current Wildcat coach Pat Fitzgerald has been all-too-happy to keep the Iowa hate a-flowin'.  

Yet there's a fundamental imbalance in the rivalry; the origins of the hate from the Armani Mafia side of things has as much to do with the fact that Iowa serves as a useful measuring stick for their own program as it does from off-hand comments from Hayden Fry (Hayden liked to quip; only a truly insecure coach or program would get that bent out of shape about a tossed-off one-liner) or getting beaten down 21 years in a row (Iowa was far from the only team to beat the shit out of jNW in the Time Before History Began).  But the reverse is not true at all: there's not an Iowa fan in existence who would measure the Iowa program against the Northwestern program.  

There's also the fact that all of Northwestern's recent wins over Iowa have yet to truly cost them anything of tangible value; indeed, they've usually wound up with a better record and/or better bowl trip anyway.  In 2005, Northwestern won, Iowa lost, the two teams ended up with identical records... and Northwestern went to the Sun Bowl while Iowa went to the Outback Bowl.  In 2006, Northwestern won, Iowa lost... and Northwestern wound up 4-8 and Iowa went 6-6 and went to the Alamo Bowl.  In 2008, Northwestern won, Iowa lost, the two teams ended up with identical records... and Northwestern went to the Alamo Bowl while Iowa went to the Outback Bowl.  In 2009, Northwestern won, Iowa lost... and Northwestern went to the Outback Bowl while Iowa went to the Orange Bowl. Even after the loss last year, Iowa still had an opportunity to win the Big Ten and go to the Rose Bowl with a win over Ohio State. Some people would argue that the loss to jNW cost Iowa a shot at a national title last year but (a) even a 12-0 Iowa team wasn't assured a spot over 12-0 Alabama and 12-0 Texas and (b) the pain of that loss would probably feel a lot more acute if they had finished the regular season at 11-1 (call it the 2002 Iowa State principle).  All those recent losses are annoying -- aggravating, even -- but that's true of all losses, particularly of the repeated variety.  Iowa lost a pair of games to Indiana in '06-07 (and more before that in the late '90s and early '00s) and a pair to Western Michigan in the '00s -- that doesn't make them rivals.

All of which is a long-winded way of saying: fuck Northwestern.  Our rivalry dance card is pretty full already and we need to find a little room for those arrogant cornhusking folks to the west.  Go find a rival that has time to care about you for more than the one week a year when you're on the schedule.

What's the one thing you should know about Northwestern?  The fact that their own cheerleaders don't even like them ranks pretty high up there, but there's one truly correct answer here -- Pat Fitzgerald is a goddamn evil wizard:

Fitzwizard_medium

Finally, photographic proof of Fitzgerald's evil wizardness. (H/T to the immortal HFMR, of course.)

Why has Jim Delany never investigated this serious breach of conduct?  Is he operating under the influence of one of Wizgerald's evil spells?  He needs to get this penny ante expansion bullshit squared away so that he can get to the bottom of the real issues affecting the Big Ten, like the black magic being employed at jNW.

How many of these fools were around a year ago?  Six dudes on offense (including 3/5 of the offensive line), six dudes on defense (including all three starters at linebacker), and the punter. 

What should we expect when Northwestern has the ball?  Dink and dunk passing and lots of it.  A Northwestern QB has ranked among the top two in pass attempts in the Big Ten in five of the last six seasons and in each of those seasons the QB in question threw for 400+ attempts... and usually well past that 400 attempt mark.  Last year, for instance, Mike Kafka tossed the ball 492 times, a figure that includes the mind-numbing 78 attempts he had in the Outback Bowl.  Suffice to say, Northwestern likes to hoist the rock and that doesn't seem likely to change, no matter how much lip service they give to concepts like a better running game or a more balanced offense.  After Kafka's one-year residency at the QB1 position, his replacement is expected to be Dan Persa, who went 20/34, 224 yards, 2 TD/2 INT and tacked on 167 rushing yards on 49 carries.  Persa is supposed to be more of a runner and could be expected to help shore up the jNW rushing attack... except we heard largely the same stuff about Kafka last year and he only went and through the ball almost 500 times and led the league in passing yards.  So, yeah, Persa's probably going to chuck it quite a bit and if the track record of jNW QBs in the last decade is any indication, he'll probably be at least decent.

The running game was Northwestern's biggest offensive weakness a year ago; they finished 8th overall in all games among Big Ten teams in rushing the ball (and 9th in conference-only games).  If you factor out sack yardage, Mike Kafka would have been the team's leading rusher by a landslide (almost 200 yards more than the actual leading rusher), albeit at a meager 519 yards.  True freshman Arby Fields was the leading runner among actual running backs (82-302-5), followed by Scott Concannon (68-241-2) and Stephen Simmons (59-233-2).  All three are back this year and between their experience and the experience along the offensive line, it's hard to see the running game being as woeful as it was in '09.  Still, jNW has ranked in the bottom half of the league in rushing in each of the last four seasons; until we see proof to the contrary, we're going to operate under the assumption that none of these guys are the second coming of Darnell Autry or even Noah Herron or Tyrell Sutton.  They're just dudes.

Northwestern's prolific, dink-and-dunk spread passing attack means lots of balls to be caught and lots of gaudy receiving stats.  A year ago, Andrew Brewer (57-925-9) and Zeke Markshausen (91-858-3) led the way, but both guys are off doing copious amounts of blow in their new Porsches out of eligibility, so new faces will need to step up and fill their void.  First in line?  That would be Drake Dunsmore (47-523-3) and Sidney Stewart (47-420-2), last year's third and fourth most productive receivers.  (And, frankly, the fact that jNW has receivers named Drake and Sidney seems utterly right; it's a wonder they haven't lobbied the NCAA to make monocles, ascots, waistcoats, and spats a permanent part of their uniforms; instead they'll have to make do with these retro unis.)  Jeremy Ebert (21-226-0) and Demetrius Fields (24-225-1) are the other primary options at WR; no one else has any experience of note.

Finally, keying the way for the entire Northwestern offensive attack will be an offensive line that returns three of five starters -- everyone but sophomore RT Patrick Ward, who did see action in 12 games a year ago.  C Ben Burkett and LT Al Netter are entering their third years as regular starters; each man has started all 13 games in each of the past two seasons and picked up a little recognition along the way (Burkett was 3rd team freshman All-America two years ago, while Netter was honorable mention All-Big Ten a year ago).  Brian Mulroe and Doug Bartels are the projected starters at guard; Mulroe started the Outback Bowl last year and saw action in four games, while Bartels started 13 games at RG in '09.  This could be one of the Big Ten's better offensive lines in 2010 and if they can find the correct algorithm for the problem that is their AWOL running game, they could have a really potent offense.

Comment 64 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

The Beginning of History? lawl

By the way, anyone planning on going to this game? Think I’m going to get a group together to go up and key some Porsches.

A Voice From Kinnick - A Hawkeye Blog

by mikjones24 on Aug 27, 2010 12:24 PM CDT reply actions  

If I am to return to the Medill School of Journalizm ,,,,,,,

I went to get tickets here
http://www.wildkatranch.com/
but it doesn’t look like it is on Lake Michigan

Greg Marmalard: But Delta's already on probation.
Dean Vernon Wormer: They are? Well, as of this moment, they're on DOUBLE SECRET PROBATION!
Animal House, 1978

by OhioHawk on Aug 29, 2010 7:11 AM CDT up reply actions  

Really, you should know better

if there are fans at that game, odds are, they’re our fans

It never gets to be easy

by chitownhawkeye on Aug 27, 2010 6:05 PM CDT up reply actions  

No, I must've missed it.

And I realize that Iowa fans will fill the stadium. I wanted to know if any FOTP were going.

So excuuuuse me.

A Voice From Kinnick - A Hawkeye Blog

by mikjones24 on Aug 27, 2010 10:25 PM CDT up reply actions  

Sorry

If I came across as an ass, I didn’t mean it. I was just being sarcastic. There’s definitely going to be FOTP there. As it was mentioned before, I’m not aware of any talk about specifically where we’re going to tailgate, but I’m sure we’ll figure out a location to meet and tailgate.

It never gets to be easy

by chitownhawkeye on Aug 27, 2010 10:32 PM CDT up reply actions  

There was a rec'd post on top of the FanPosts for a few weeks with info.

But, yes, there will be a contingent of BHGP faithful at this game. We’re still trying to sort out what to do for the tailgate since the tailgating around Ryan Field is apparently the drizzling shits.

"I want to be a cowboy. I don't want to be a panda. Pandas are boring, stupid and boring. Bad panda!"

by RossWB on Aug 27, 2010 11:54 PM CDT up reply actions  

Tacos the night before.

1.Party at my house
2.Drunkenly stagger over to the El Gallo Bravo #6 two blocks away @ about 11PM
3.Finish whatever beer we didn’t get to before thought eating Mexican at that hour was a good idea.
4.Wake up hung-over and stomach-stricken and pray the tailgate doesn’t kill us.

Less memorable than Sam Okey's Hawkeye career.

by Kyle McCann't on Aug 28, 2010 10:20 AM CDT up reply actions  

Ah, that's probably why I missed it

I have tunnel vision when it comes to the FanPosts. I know a few people who have tailgated there before and I’m going to ask them what the general situation is. But to follow your lead, yes, they say it’s just a real nightmare to tailgate.

A Voice From Kinnick - A Hawkeye Blog

by mikjones24 on Aug 28, 2010 9:21 AM CDT up reply actions  

The Band

The band is going to the game which will equal the entire northwestern fan base in numbers i’m sure.

by Wayms on Aug 29, 2010 10:41 PM CDT up reply actions  

Please...

…Porsches are so 2009. We drive Bugattis now.

by jabawacefti on Aug 27, 2010 12:58 PM CDT reply actions  

Great write-up as always, Ross,

but I wish you would not have linked to Pat Hardy. I just threw up a delicious $25 lunch.

"Oh no, don't do that, don't do that. If you shoot him, you'll just make him mad." - The Waco Kid

by HawkOnRails on Aug 27, 2010 1:16 PM CDT via mobile reply actions  

Hmm.

I should’ve put a content warning there, perhaps.

"I want to be a cowboy. I don't want to be a panda. Pandas are boring, stupid and boring. Bad panda!"

by RossWB on Aug 27, 2010 1:47 PM CDT up reply actions  

The HFMR thread made me laugh until I cried then I laughed again

I have dreams of chocolate cake shake.

the trailer hitch scrotum was my idea

by Kluginator on Aug 27, 2010 1:51 PM CDT reply actions  

Fuck Northwestern. Fuck ’em right in the ear.

by edr247 on Aug 27, 2010 2:10 PM CDT reply actions  

Minor correction...

“How many of these fools were around a year ago? Six dudes on offense (including 3/5 of the offensive line), six dudes on defense (including all three starters at linebacker), and the punter.”

Fuck tOSU

by ajs1122 on Aug 27, 2010 3:05 PM CDT reply actions  

I will disregard jNW when we have beaten them handily a few times

I hate the team, fans and their DB coach but whether we want to admit it or not, that DB coach has gotten his team up for Iowa better than Iowa has been up for jNW. Last year I thought Ferentz was finally taking the game seriously then Stanzi got hurt .

the trailer hitch scrotum was my idea

by Kluginator on Aug 27, 2010 3:47 PM CDT reply actions  

Waiting for part 2

Stop making fun of Ryan Field. Ryan field is very family friendly. So family friendly, families often stayed later than all the alums who realized the game was out of hand and left. Kids got to run around all over the stands without really bugging anyone. Cheaper than babysitters too.

It’s real cute to see kids explaining the road team will be working for the home team some day. And if you don’t think so, you have no family values.

Also, thanks for the upcoming Purdue report even though Purdue gets to avoid ’em. Win win for us Boiler fans.

by Beavis Beefcake on Aug 27, 2010 4:05 PM CDT reply actions  

I hope they beat Vandy handily.

Then we can loudly proclaim to the SEC, “Our nerds can beat your nerds!”

by HawkeyeRecon on Aug 27, 2010 6:01 PM CDT reply actions  

Like anyone in the SEC

cares about academics.

I ate the blue ones ... they taste like burning.

by HoyaGoon on Aug 27, 2010 11:10 PM CDT up reply actions  

Only Vandy

And somehow Florida manages to be a good school, at least good enough for AAU membership and decent rankings.

by PackerHawk on Aug 27, 2010 11:37 PM CDT up reply actions  

I'm sure Florida keeps that quiet from their SEC brethern

lest that get out and make Florida look like the actually attempt to focus on academics.

I ate the blue ones ... they taste like burning.

by HoyaGoon on Aug 28, 2010 1:44 AM CDT up reply actions  

Tailgating Spots

I will be there with a group of Hawk fans. Any recommendations on tailgating spots?

by MSA_Hawk on Aug 27, 2010 8:39 PM CDT reply actions  

I don't think we've discussed it yet.

but we’ll get something figured out.

It never gets to be easy

by chitownhawkeye on Aug 27, 2010 10:15 PM CDT up reply actions  

Tailgating at Ryan sucks.

There aren’t really any great spots unless you have a parking space right next to the stadium. Part of me almost thinks it’s a good idea to see if there are any BHGP’ers off far enough up the Red/Purple line to jump straight on the L after a morning get-together.

Less memorable than Sam Okey's Hawkeye career.

by Kyle McCann't on Aug 28, 2010 10:22 AM CDT up reply actions  

I-Clubs & Iowa Bars

I’ve also been thinking about just going to one of the Iowa friendly bars instead of setting up the tailgate — to your point, then just taking the train to the game.

by MSA_Hawk on Aug 28, 2010 10:46 AM CDT up reply actions  

My thought as well.

Is it an 11am kick? A train ride from Merkle’s all the way up might take a bit too long to have that be the pregame non-tailgate tailgate place, but maybe picking SOME place off the Red Line might be better than trying to cobble together an actual tailgate.


"All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again."

by Bucketochicken on Aug 28, 2010 12:29 PM CDT up reply actions  

No time set yet.

I think it probably will be an 11am kick-off, but we’ll have to wait and see. If Iowa and jNW get off to great starts to the season (entirely possible, especially since jNW has a cake schedule; see pt 2 coming on Monday), ABC might grab it for the 2:30pm start.+

"I want to be a cowboy. I don't want to be a panda. Pandas are boring, stupid and boring. Bad panda!"

by RossWB on Aug 28, 2010 2:26 PM CDT up reply actions  

The last time I was there

we set up in a parking lot that nowhere near the campus, and before the game there was some sort of bus / transport that was going around to all the parking lots and picking people up. It wasn’t great, but it did work, and then the bus took us back after the game.
I don’t know if they still do that, or if anyone else has had similar experiences, but I have no problem doing that again.

It never gets to be easy

by chitownhawkeye on Aug 28, 2010 9:22 PM CDT up reply actions  

Merkle's/Big City Tap

seem like good options. Bowman’s on Lincoln in North Centre is a newly-converted Hawk bar this year, but that’s off of the Brown Line and would require a transfer at Belmont. Or if there’s a Hawk fan living in Roger’s Park or Uptown that wouldn’t mind a bunch of idiots on their lawn for a few hours that could work as well.

Less memorable than Sam Okey's Hawkeye career.

by Kyle McCann't on Aug 29, 2010 12:27 AM CDT up reply actions  

Please not BCT...

I’m not sure I’ve ever been there and remember leaving

"I shoot, I score. He shoots, I score." - Dan Gable

by ClaybornSmash on Aug 29, 2010 12:37 AM CDT up reply actions  

I went there for the NIU game two years ago.

That game was so boring that I had to keep drinking just to stay marginally interested in being awake. But watching Michigan lose to Appy St. as an appetizer (see what I did there) was fun. At this point I’m leaning towards Merkle’s.

Honestly, maybe we could cut a deal with Merkle’s to open early and “host” us if we could guarantee them a certain turnout. Is this worth a shot? Would anyone like me to do the legwork?

Less memorable than Sam Okey's Hawkeye career.

by Kyle McCann't on Aug 29, 2010 12:44 AM CDT up reply actions  

Big City is terrible.

It used to be cool, but has become really ghetto & crappy the past few years. Merkle’s is infinitely better, as is Four Shadows.


"All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again."

by Bucketochicken on Aug 29, 2010 1:43 AM CDT up reply actions  

Four Shadows is on Ashland, right?

i.e. like a stones-throw from your doorstep. That must suck…

Regardless, should we try to rent out a place or just congregate?

Less memorable than Sam Okey's Hawkeye career.

by Kyle McCann't on Aug 29, 2010 2:09 AM CDT up reply actions  

Ashland & Diversey, yeah.

It’s ok.


"All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again."

by Bucketochicken on Aug 29, 2010 9:36 AM CDT up reply actions  

Thanks Ross. Well done as always. Reserving hate for others while continuing apathy for the doucher that is Fitz and his team.

by txhawkeye on Aug 28, 2010 12:02 AM CDT reply actions  

Apathy hasn't been working against them lately...

…so I borrowed some of my hate for Minny (since they’re in shambles, much like old school jNW, so it’s hard to hate them much… I’ll hate them again after/whenever they score on us) and transfered it to Evanston.
Not a lot of hate, but it’s cold and crushing hate.

by Eyeheartfreedumb on Aug 30, 2010 1:32 PM CDT up reply actions  

Legwork

If you don’t mind checking on options, that would be appreciated. I did see on the Bowman site that they open at 9:00 AM for Hawkeye games. Perhaps, they’d open earlier to accommodate fans going to the game. If it does end up being a later kickoff, this might not matter. I’m open to bringing my tailgate gear to one of the parking lots with shuttle service if the bars don’t work out. FOTPs invited, of course.

FWIW, I recently moved to Iowa City (from Minneapolis). I did my undergrad here 89-93. We moved as my wife accepted a professor position at Iowa. She said that her two dream jobs were University of Toronto or UI. My response was the Hawkeyes don’t play in Toronto. So here we are. I’m starting to get my home game tailgate legs under me. Became a fan of this site because of Morehouse (I worked with his wife for a while last year).

Keep me posted on bar vs tailgate status.

by MSA_Hawk on Aug 29, 2010 9:55 AM CDT reply actions  

D'oh

The above post should have been indented to stay with the tailgate spot / bar conversation. User error is generating much shame.

by MSA_Hawk on Aug 29, 2010 9:58 AM CDT up reply actions  

Don't look now, but ...

“The running game was Northwestern’s biggest offensive weakness a year ago; they finished 8th overall in all games among Big Ten teams in rushing the ball (and 9th in conference-only games). If you factor out sack yardage, Mike Kafka would have been the team’s leading rusher by a landslide (almost 200 yards more than the actual leading rusher), albeit at a meager 519 yards.”

It seems that they finished two spots ahead of Iowa in Big Ten rushing figures. They ran more than we did, they accumulated more yards than we did, and they scored 40% more touchdowns on the ground than we did. And we sent three or four OL guys to NFL camps.

So if their run game is a “weakness”, I hope that ours is a weakness as well this year. My concern is that everyone thinks Iowa is O-line U, but we finished behind Indiana last year. Something in this tells me that we need more than three offensive rush plays, absent an NFL running back.

I confess that I do not understand the hate and invective v. Northwestern because they seem like good guys with a good coach from a good school that is neither in contention for the Fullmer Cup nor the NCAA Bozo School of the Month Club. And they beat us fair and square with some regularity.

Mr. Boh Knows ...

by Bellanca on Aug 29, 2010 11:37 AM CDT reply actions  

I don't get it either.

I like jNWU, and Coach Fitz is awesome. I totally get the good-natured ribbing & teasing them for being out-of-touch wealthy yacht club elitists and such, and the “just” meme is funny because they’ve beaten us so often lately, but any actual hate & invective, no, I don’t really get it either. jNWU, along with Penn State, is a very easy team for me to root for.


"All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again."

by Bucketochicken on Aug 29, 2010 12:03 PM CDT up reply actions  

Well...
They ran more than we did, they accumulated more yards than we did, and they scored 40% more touchdowns on the ground than we did. And we sent three or four OL guys to NFL camps.

They also ran almost 200 more offensive plays than we did; I’d expect them to have more rushing attempts and more rushing yards. They averaged 3.0 ypc as a team; that’s pretty poor. Was Iowa also poor? Yes.

So if their run game is a "weakness", I hope that ours is a weakness as well this year. My concern is that everyone thinks Iowa is O-line U, but we finished behind Indiana last year. Something in this tells me that we need more than three offensive rush plays, absent an NFL running back.

That might help. Having the same five guys healthy and on the field for more than a game or two might also produce better results. Not trying to run the ball with two freshman running backs shouldn’t hurt.

Northwestern has had fairly poor running games for a while now; they’ve been able to mitigate that problem by getting a lot of offensive production out of their passing game. If our running game remains as weak as Northwestern’s, our offense could be in a lot of trouble considering that we rely on it to be much more of our total offense than Northwestern does (although this year we might have the pieces to be a good passing offense, too).

And they beat us fair and square with some regularity.

This is probably a more apt discussion after part two, but… By what, never outright cheating? I suppose if that’s your definition then that’s true. They’ve also been the recipient of incredible good fortune and freak plays in three of their four wins over Iowa in the last half-decade. I have never once thought after one of those games that Northwestern was the superior team. (Even in 2006; they were clearly the better team on the field that day, but overall that was a lousy NW team, even compared to the imploding squad Iowa fielded that year.) And, look, I fully understand how much that sounds like just sour grapes, but so be it.

They have never finished with a better record than Iowa in that span. They have three wins over ranked, non-Iowa opposition in that span (and one of them is over Minnesota in 2007; in hindsight, it’s utterly farcical that that Minnesota team was ranked). They make our struggles with Ohio State look like nothing (they played OSU four times in 05-09; average score: OSU 51, NW 9) and in fact they have been routinely bludgeoned by the “Big Three” (OSU, PSU, Michigan) in the league in that span; their lone win was over Michigan’s hapless 2008 squad and they haven’t been terribly close in most of the losses over that span.

They bleat and moan about not getting respect by pollsters, media pundits and bowls, then produce attendance totals more befitting a 4-8 squad than an 8-4 team, consistently come up short in big moments against everyone aside from Iowa (and Wisconsin, oddly enough… or not so oddly, given the similarities between Iowa and Wisconsin), and produce consistently inconsistent results and drop games they shouldn’t (they haven’t lost fewer than four games in a season since 1996). They produce almost one faceplant per season, like making Greg Paulus look nearly all-Conference a year ago or getting smashed by New Hampshire in 2006 or conceding the biggest comeback victory in I-A history to Michigan State that same year. Or losing to Duke in 2007 and Indiana in 2008. Etc. They would prefer that you ignore that anything prior to the mid-90s ever happened and they fixate upon the Iowa game with a disproportionate passion. If they played with the same focus and passion they have in the Iowa game in other games (particularly against lesser opposition), they’d have more wins and more respect.

Sound like anyone else we know? As a fanbase and a program, they are in many ways Iowa State with a trust fund — although at least they managed to attain greater success at their height in the mid-90s.

"I want to be a cowboy. I don't want to be a panda. Pandas are boring, stupid and boring. Bad panda!"

by RossWB on Aug 29, 2010 1:03 PM CDT up reply actions  

Well said, Ross

and I completely agree. Until Fitz came along, I was completely indifferent to jNW. Now, I want to pound them if only to shut them up. I’m definitely reserving much more hate for other squads, but I just can’t stand jNW for the reasons you stated.

by Brock8144 on Aug 29, 2010 1:20 PM CDT up reply actions  

Look, they square up and hit. They show up and play. They beat us.

Their ypc was only 9% weaker than ours — and we are a run-first team. Not a run-to-change-it-up team.

Freak plays or not, they’re winning on the scoreboard. The rest of the year we’re the guys who are saying that it doesn’t matter that we squeak by UNI. Hayden didn’t lose to these guys. I think we should figure out why we now lose to these guys.

Fitzgerald and the athletes have nothing to do with whatever attendance figures they marshall.

Last, I think the whole ISU-with-a-trust-fund thing also has nothing to do with the football team. I respect the football team. I suspect KF does too, because he struggles with them.

I’m arguing here to put some humility on the table, and not doing the maize-and-blue thing which is to say, acting uppity because we put up 66 20 years ago.

Anyway, Ross, your profiles are thorough and professional, very interesting, and provocative. I can’t say that about the random column inches in the Register.

Mr. Boh Knows ...

by Bellanca on Aug 29, 2010 1:37 PM CDT up reply actions  

I really think our simple-is-better offense is on the bubble this year.

If it’s my team: we go run-to-pass. In truth, we were last year (by statistics), but it wasn’t terribly obvious, and it was a couple of quarters of ugly ball each week.

KF and KOK have to be reviewing the great years in the early oughts, when we were averaging 30+ points per game with rookie QBs, and Pete Carroll was saying we had the most impressive offensive scheme he studied.

Of course, with the rush to spread the field, we are now the outlier offense, an interesting idea all by itself. “Coach! A tight end. What’s a tight end?” And, note, our #2 fullback is a genuine ballcarrier, not just a small guard.

The Shadow knows — what will happen.

Mr. Boh Knows ...

by Bellanca on Aug 29, 2010 1:42 PM CDT up reply actions  

Yeah, my liking of jNWU's team and coach

is completely separate from my feelings regarding (many of) their fans. And even most of that is based solely on interactions on the internet, which is only sort of real.


"All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again."

by Bucketochicken on Aug 29, 2010 1:43 PM CDT up reply actions  

I agree that jNW does things the right way and produces against Iowa

what I don’t appreciate is their fans reaction to their wins over us being so smug and superior when they are obviously inferior teams based off of record. Its one thing if we’re both 8-4 teams and jNW beats us. They can claim they’re better based off of that fact and I will accept it. It’s when we’re 11-2 and OB champs over the ACC champ, and they are still talking to us about being a better team with an Outback Bowl loss that it starts to grate on my nerves. In short, if jNW can achieve an equal or better record than us, I can respect their trash talk. If they fail to do that and only get up for our game, then they are exactly like ISU and deserve to be treated as such by us.

"I shoot, I score. He shoots, I score." - Dan Gable

by ClaybornSmash on Aug 29, 2010 3:44 PM CDT up reply actions  

The superior team on any given Saturday?

That’s the one with more points on the board.

Iowa is usually a strong-finishing team, one that sets out to play a developmental season. I doubt that any NW folks would call the GT game a fluke.

But the superior team in November? That would be the one with more points on the board.

Mr. Boh Knows ...

by Bellanca on Aug 29, 2010 4:51 PM CDT up reply actions  

If the above is not true,

then UNI was a loss last year. Iowa played superior football — for the last two plays of the game, only. But we had more points.

Mr. Boh Knows ...

by Bellanca on Aug 29, 2010 4:52 PM CDT up reply actions  

2008....

….would like to have a word with you. Not to rehash everything, but Northwestern had a better record (9-3 vs. 8-4), and a head-to-head win over Iowa….and got passed over in favor of Iowa for the Outback Bowl.

Hey, Iowa is a bigger attendance draw, and bowls are about selling tickets (although Northwestern sells bowl tickets well since they have fans/alumni all over the country….which inversely hurts them in Evanston, since a lot of alums leave), so Iowa got a good bowl and Northwestern went to San Antonio (which was fun too)…..but there was some statements to the effect that Iowa was a better team that year. Not true, based on your own criteria.

by Chadnudj on Aug 30, 2010 9:40 AM CDT up reply actions  

What were the scores of the jNW losses?

The sum of Iowa’s four losses was 12 points. I can see how that mitigates a loss or two. But I see what you’re saying.

by Eyeheartfreedumb on Aug 30, 2010 1:45 PM CDT up reply actions  

I agree that 2008 was weird

We had a great football team that lost every close game we had (including jNW). We ended showing the ESS-EEE-SEE what was up when we killed them in the Outback Bowl, but you’re right that jNW should’ve gotten that bid instead of us based on on-field performance.

But then again, one year does not a trend make. I’m too lazy to look it up but I’m pretty sure that most of jNW’s wins against Iowa occurred in years where Iowa finished with a better record. As Eyeheart said, we’ve never been “blownout” by jNW as well. It’s always been one or two plays that determine the course of the game. When Iowa plays Penn State, we get those bounces. When Iowa plays jNW we don’t. I think jNW is actually a very good program since Fitz took over but I don’t look at any of our recent losses and think to myself “Well Northwestern was obviously the better team”.

The point of my post was to point out the fact that jNW fans do sound a lot like ISU fans when we lose to them. In 2002 when ISU beat us for our only loss before going to the Orange Bowl all I heard from my cyclone friends was about how ISU was better because they beat us. We were 11-1 and going to a BCS game. They were 7-6. Same situation last year. Same things being said. On that day, yes you beat us. One day is not an entire season though.

"I shoot, I score. He shoots, I score." - Dan Gable

by ClaybornSmash on Aug 30, 2010 2:09 PM CDT up reply actions  

I don't think any....

….Northwestern fans thought we were a “better” team in 2009 than Iowa….just better on the one day that counted, when we played. Iowa clearly was a better team over the course of the season, and rightfully ended up in a BCS bowl game because of it.

As for lucky bounces, I’m of the belief that you make your own luck. Iowa does a great job of doing that against PSU….Northwestern seems to capitalize and do it against Iowa recently. There’s nothing “lucky” about that….just teams capitalizing on opportunities — both Iowa and Northwestern (or any team) should get credit when they win for putting themselves in position to take the lucky bounces and use them to win.

by Chadnudj on Aug 30, 2010 2:23 PM CDT up reply actions  

I don't think we disagree that much re: the running game for Iowa...

It was poor last year and needs to be better. There are legitimate reasons to think it could be better, even with the loss of some highly-decorated names from a year ago. Aside from that…

Freak plays or not, they’re winning on the scoreboard. The rest of the year we’re the guys who are saying that it doesn’t matter that we squeak by UNI. Hayden didn’t lose to these guys. I think we should figure out why we now lose to these guys.

We should try to gameplan not to have our best offensive player get injured when we play them? We should try to gameplan not have our kick and punt returners have their only fumbles of the season when we play them? We should try not to roll out our QB deep in our own end zone? Okay… that one we probably should do. And there are certain other things — like staying away from more avoidable turnovers like throwing into zone blitzes (something that caught Stanzi in ‘08 and Vandenberg in ’09) or the bad INT that Stanzi threw in the second quarter last year when we were up 10-0 (and that inadvertently set up that disastrous series in the endzone, since our defense stuffed NW after the INT, only for their punt to put our offense in the shadow of the endzone). That stuff does need to get cleaned up. But there have been so many other strange, freakish, ultimately random plays that have gone against Iowa in these games over the last five years that I’m not sure what can be done to avoid them.

And the other reason Hayden didn’t lose to them? They’re better now. Much better. I would never dream of denying that.

Fitzgerald and the athletes have nothing to do with whatever attendance figures they marshall.

Last, I think the whole ISU-with-a-trust-fund thing also has nothing to do with the football team. I respect the football team. I suspect KF does too, because he struggles with them.

I think he does, too. I think he respects everyone we play. And I understand that those issues have little to do with the football team itself, but they are part of the entire package that is “Northwestern football” and they feed into the feelings among Iowa fans here and elsewhere. (And to clarify: the “ISU with a trust fund” thing was a glib remark: I think they do have some similarities [maybe more than our NW friends would care to admit], but ultimately NW has been more successful than ISU over the past 10-15 years… I’m not denying that.)

That said, the fixation on Iowa extends beyond their fanbase — it was something clearly set up by Barnett and something that’s been furthered by Fitzgerald and the current players. Fitzgerald has tried to downplay it at times, but there have been enough interviews with players where they singled out Iowa as their primary rival and their level of focus and passion against Iowa vs. other teams is clear enough to suggest that it’s still a part of their program. And maybe we should be flattered by that, but I find it annoying because the same team that plays us so well is just as likely to turn around shit the bed against Minnesota or Indiana (programs that they should be better than) the next week.

I also think it’s limiting from a strategic/program-building standpoint. It made sense to make Iowa an aspirational and inspirational target when Barnett took over in the ‘90s: our success seemed attainable (moreso than Michigan’s or Ohio State’s level of success) and 15 years of losing can certainly go a long way in fueling a grudge. But ultimately it strikes me as a limiting approach: you continue to spend so much energy on one team that you don’t have enough left for all of the other teams on the schedule. I think Ferentz’s more even keel approach is better-suited to building a consistent winner that can challenge for top honors. (Of course that approach has some flaws, too: it requires you to have a reasonably high level of talent to counter the threat of less-talented, but uber-motivated teams… and even then those games can still be worrisome at times.) I think a tangentially related issue there is that KF has created a mindset in the team where anyone is beatable and that we fear no one, which I think partially accounts for Iowa’s ability to be successful and competitive against everyone, even the B10 elites like Michigan and Ohio State. You never see good Iowa teams get mauled like NW has by Ohio State over the last five years. I’m not convinced NW goes into that game thinking that they can beat Ohio State.

I think you rarely find elite teams that fixate on a single team, either, even teams with major rivals; Ohio State recognizes the Michigan game as being important, but at the same time their primary goals are still Big Ten titles and national titles.

Anyway, Ross, your profiles are thorough and professional, very interesting, and provocative. I can’t say that about the random column inches in the Register.

Thanks. And as I’m sure has been discussed on here before, the Register sports pages haven’t been consistently good since they dropped “the Big Peach” and they haven’t even been readable for a few years now. That paper should stand as a prime example of the potential ills of corporate homogenization; that was once a great newspaper and it has been utterly gutted, post-Gannett takeover.

"I want to be a cowboy. I don't want to be a panda. Pandas are boring, stupid and boring. Bad panda!"

by RossWB on Aug 29, 2010 4:46 PM CDT up reply actions  

Two words - Iowa turnovers

the trailer hitch scrotum was my idea

by Kluginator on Aug 29, 2010 9:09 PM CDT up reply actions  

I think that should be:

Two words: Iowa Hawkeye turnovers

I ate the blue ones ... they taste like burning.

by HoyaGoon on Aug 30, 2010 9:58 AM CDT up reply actions  

Let us not forget

Wegher’s touchdown run that was called back for a pancake block.

by HawKCP on Aug 30, 2010 2:38 PM CDT up reply actions  

In the end the Northwestern game had no great affect on our season

we would have lost the Rose Bowl tie breaker anyway. We likely would have gone to the Orange Bowl anyway. Maybe I am being to simple about it but it seems to me the game to win last year was the Ohio State game. It will likely be that way this year too.

I think the tools are in place for a slight reorientation of Iowa offensive football. Very experienced QBs allow you to do things, if you have time. So the O-line is important. It can’t be worse than last year though, can it? I guess it can.

If we can keep Stanzi clean though we can be an even more pro oriented team this year. If KOK calls the game right we can look on paper like KF wants us to look. More running plays than passing plays that is. But we need to play action and drop back pass on first down considerably more. Way more. We need to keep teams honest and exploit man-to-man coverage. I would like to see more passes on 2nd and 5 too. I loved the game plan against Iowa State last year. I liked the game plan in the first quarter against Georgia Tech too.I am eager to see how we play teams.

"I wish you luck with a capital 'F'" - The Real Elvis.

by StoopsMyAss on Aug 31, 2010 3:56 PM CDT up reply actions  

"off-hand comments from Hayden Fry"

Iowa hawkeyes broke Fitzgerald’s leg!!! And still lost by 31 to 20!!!

by Iowa broke Fitzgerald's leg!!! on Sep 18, 2010 8:08 PM CDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"It’s so extreme, it’s almost a compliment."

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Tractor_small
Sherlock Holmes: The Story of the Missing Offense. Chpt. 4
Tractor_small
Sherlock Holmes: The Story of the Missing Offense. Chpt. 3

Recent FanPosts

Default_small
Iowa is Honoring the 86-87 Hoops Team Tomorrow
Default_small
University of Iowa Students are the Worst Dancers in the World
Trailer-park-boys_mr-lahey_small
AIRBHG Fixes his gaze to the west...
Dumpster_fire_small
Hamsterdam Likes Clashing Kings
Brands-e1283460585550-150x150_small
Senior Bowl Report
Dumpster_fire_small
Hamsterdam Is Ready For The Weekend
Small
#HireAdamJacobi
Small
Show some love this Valentine's Day- Help Sick Kids
Dumpster_fire_small
Hamsterdam Has Found The Pinnacle Of Music And Art At Last

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Mcqueen_small Patrick Vint

Louie_small Adam Jacobi

Stains_small jebushchrist

Dumpster_fire_small RossWB

Default_small PSD

Authors

Images_small StoopsMyAss

Spitzenhofen_small Hayden Fry's Moustache Ride

Herky_small hawk6894

Horace_small Horace E. Cow