HD Replay
So I was killing some time on my lunch hour over at Deadspin when I came across a link to the following article:
Reading through this article left me at a complete loss. How in the world can the omgSEC conference not be using high definition TV's for their in booth replay reviews. I understand old people don't understand HD, but come on. This is beyond rediculous and bordering on criminal. There really is no excuse for it, and the director of officials should be fired for not seeing any benefit to HD. He is clearly incompetent.
The more I thought about it though, I'm wondering if the Big Ten is in the same fucked up situation. It might better explain the blown call (and it was) in the Indiana game. Everyone watching at home or in the bar with an HDTV could clearly see the field turf pellets kicked up during the toe drag and the receiver definitely had possesion. There is no way the call on the field should have been overturned. On the other hand, If the booth referee was forced to watch it in standard def, I can see those details being missed. I'm sure there are other examples this year across the conference but this is the most glaring that I can recall that makes me question the effectiveness of replay in the Big Ten.
OPS or Hawkeye State, is there anyone you have contact with in the Big Ten that can confirm whether the Big Ten uses HD for reviews whenever possible for conference games? Is it used for all out of conference and Big Ten bowl games? As a college football fan, I am geniunely interested and a little concerned. There is no way that me half awake and hungover on my living room couch should be better equiped to judge a game changing call than the referee in the booth.
-ajs
0 recs |
9 comments
|
Comments
Blown call?

No self-respecting man from Iowa goes anywhere without beer
by Hayden Fry's Moustache Ride on Nov 11, 2009 2:35 PM CST reply actions
Yes
Don’t get me wrong, I love that Iowa was the beneficiary of the mistake. It was just that there is no doubt in my mind that it was the wrong call. Indiana had every right to feel like they got jobbed on that one, and it very well may have affected the outcome of the game. Referees are human and they make mistakes. I’m not here to bust on the officiating.
My point is that if the referees in the booth aren’t given the best equipment to make the correct call, than that is an injustice. It is the conference’s responsibility to put their referees in position to make the correct call. In my mind it is inexcusable to say that the equipment is adequate when for $1000, it is possible to have ~6 times the resolution of a standard definition broadcast. In my mind that is a sound investment for a billion dollar entity to make to protect their credibility. While in the majority of cases the equipment may be “adequate”, there is no doubt there are times when it will come up short and it WILL affect the outcome of games. In my mind, that is unacceptable.
I don’t know what equipment is used by the Big Ten and perhaps they are already on top of their game, but in my mind it is a question that absolutely should be answered. The SEC has already admitted that they use inferior equipment and have no plans to change. They should be called out on this and if the Big Ten is in the same position, they should be as well. It is not fair to the fans, it is not fair to the teams and it is not fair to the referees.
Fuck tOSU
The Big Ten
uses puppet reenactments. They say it isn’t as accurate, but it is more fun to watch.
"I think it's safe to say our concerns are many." -- Kirk Ferentz
From what I hear, the NFL uses live actors...
They go the extra mile for the added accuracy over puppets… Based on this video replay, you can clearly see that the Viking receiver got the toe tap before being forced out by the 49ers defender.
/deadspin
Fuck tOSU
Sorry, hard to buy.
It’s just a still shot. It’s like the shot going around after the Super Bowl last year, which showed Holmes’ foot off the ground. Except when expanded, that shot was from before the ball even got to his hands. I can’t buy either verifying or debunking the call based on a still-shot.
As for the SEC with Standard-Def TV’s… I really, REALLY hope that is a false report. Because if not that is a complete and utter joke by that conference.
'They are who we thought they were!'
It's true, and it came from the director of officials' mouth.
Then he said there was nothing wrong with that and they’d be able to do their job without an upgrade. I fucking bet, dude.
I got more rhymes than Wade Lookingbill's got dunks
by Adam Jacobi on Nov 11, 2009 11:17 PM CST up reply actions
They don't need it
They’re cheap. The SEC speed helps them see replays…faster. Or something.
Sam Lickliter. Never forgive. Never forget. Beat IU.
by ReadingRambler on Nov 11, 2009 11:59 PM CST up reply actions

by 


















